Altadena Now is published daily and will host archives of Timothy Rutt's Altadena blog and his later Altadena Point sites.
Altadena Now encourages solicitation of events information, news items, announcements, photographs and videos.
Please email to: Editor@Altadena-Now.com
- James Macpherson, Editor
- Candice Merrill, Events
- Megan Hole, Lifestyles
- David Alvarado, Advertising
Sunday, November 8, 2026
Los Angeles County Public Defender, District Attorney Split Over Newsom’s Death Sentence Commutations

Public Defender Ricardo D. García and District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman
Public Defender Ricardo García praises the governor’s decision, while District Attorney Nathan Hochman says California’s death penalty law remains in force.
Los Angeles County’s top public defender and district attorney offered sharply different responses last week to Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute California’s 548 death sentences to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole, a move affecting the statewide justice system that includes Pasadena.
Public Defender Ricardo D. García praised the November 5 announcement as a step toward a more equitable justice system. District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman acknowledged the governor’s constitutional authority but emphasized that the decision does not repeal California’s death penalty or prevent prosecutors from seeking it in future cases.
The governor’s action covers the state’s existing death sentences, although some commutations require approval from the California Supreme Court before taking effect. Under California law, the court must approve commutations involving people convicted of more than one felony.
In a statement released by his office Thursday, García characterized the decision as a response to systemic problems in capital punishment.
“I commend Governor Newsom for this historic decision,” García said. “Public Defenders called for universal clemency because we see firsthand how unjust our criminal legal system is, and nowhere is that injustice more final than on death row.”
García argued that capital punishment disproportionately affects poor defendants and people of color. He also asserted that Los Angeles County has sentenced more people to death than any other California county, imposing substantial costs without improving public safety.
“Clemency is not leniency,” García said.
Hochman, in a separate statement issued the same day, focused on the continuing legal authority of prosecutors and the Legislature.
“The Governor has chosen to commute existing death sentences to life without the possibility of parole, as is within his constitutional power,” Hochman said. “But that power does not extend to eliminating the death penalty.”
Hochman noted that California voters rejected ballot measures seeking to abolish capital punishment in 2012 and 2016.
He said his office would continue reviewing death penalty-eligible cases individually, applying the existing law unless voters or legislators change it.
“My thoughts today are with the families of victims, who deserve a justice system that honors the law as it is written and pursues it with fairness and due process,” Hochman said.
California has not carried out an execution since 2006. Newsom imposed a formal moratorium in March 2019, preventing executions while leaving existing death sentences in place.
The latest action goes beyond that moratorium by reducing death sentences to life without parole, subject to the required judicial approvals. It does not overturn the underlying convictions.
For Pasadena and other Los Angeles County communities, the differing responses underscore an ongoing division among county justice officials over capital punishment, even as the governor moves to change the sentences of those already condemned.
Altadena Calendar of Events
For Pasadena Events, click here
